The Wicker Man


Never heard of THE WICKER MAN before? Neither had i, until i looked it up in the IMD and found that there is actually a cult of people who maintain that this film is "erotic", "eerie", "unsettling", "witty", "haunting", and has an unforgettable, "harrowing", "surprise" ending. Cinefantastique even dubbed this British flick "the 'Citizen Kane' of horror films."

But after thinking about it some more, i have decided that none of the people who allegedly feel this way must be real. All the reviews must be fabricated, the word-of-mouth recommending this movie nothing but a conspiracy of heathens intent on sacrificing the innocent lamb of art to the ancient god of capitalism. In plain Kings County English, this movie sucks!

THE WICKER MAN follows Police Sergeant Howie (Edward Woodward, the chap who played The Equalizer) in a trip to a remote isle to investigate a young girl's disappearance. While there, he learns that the islanders are devout pagans who are trying to cover up the girl's disappearance, even as they prepare for a ritual sacrifice during a day of harvest celebration. Deducing that the missing girl is to be the sacrifice, Howie becomes obsessed with finding her before it's too late.

The ending of the movie is something you can spot from about an hour away, especially if you've read Shirley Jackson's most famous short story, or even seen the 80's Twilight Zone episode about the doctor and the lighthouse. But that's not even the main problem here - plenty of great classic stories are predictable.

The problem boils down to this: the character of Sergeant Howie is so unsympathetic, so tiresome, and, in the scene where he fights off a seduction attempt, so just plain ridiculous, that even if you DIDN'T see the ending coming, you really wouldn't care what ultimately happens to him. everything about this guy makes you want to scream GET A LIFE. despite the fact that THE BLUE ANGEL almost put me to sleep, i do believe that a puritanical, uptight religious fanatic can be made to seem poignant or even tragic if the people writing the story have talent. sadly these people did not write THE WICKER MAN.

Also, there's this big christianity vs. paganism conflict thing going on that gets endlessly hammered in by cliched references to sacrifice and sex which i spose might seem momentarily diverting or even thought-provoking to Jerry Falwell or Trent Reznor, but NOBODY ELSE.

The nude scenes are plentiful and boring. The nature shots, instead of being grand and moving, are just nice. Nice like a no-frills postcard from Connecticut might strike you as nice. But the music, on the other hand, is awesome! Imagine the Partridge Family transported to the 13th century Scottish countryside for a month of viagra and crack. Delightfully groovy, hippy dippy shit with lyrics bawdy enough to make everybody's inner 12 year old start to grin insanely. i'm totally not being sarcastic about this, if i ever see the soundtrack, i'll buy it. even at 15 bucks it'd be cash better spent than the 3.99 plus tax i paid for this two reels o' crap film.

Grade: B-
(Note: This short review is a version of a post I posted to alt.movies.monster in the summer of 2000.)
The Palace | Meet Ming | Email Ming | Feedback Form | Fatal Planetarium | Destroy All Monsters